Supreme Court sides with high school cheerleader who cursed on social media

Supreme Court rules school wrong to punish cheerleader for profane Snapchat rant in 8-1 free speech decision

In a landmark ruling on Wednesday, the Supreme Court ruled that a Pennsylvania school district violated a student's free speech after she used explicit language regarding the school's cheerleading squad on Snapchat. The majority announced a categorical rule barring discipline for off-campus speech that seemed to limit the ability of public schools to address many kinds of disturbing communications by students on social media, including racist threats and cyberbullying.

Brandi Levy, now an 18-year-old college freshman, was a ninth grader at Mahanoy Area High School who had just failed to make the varsity cheer squad when she made a decision to air her frustrations on social media.

"F*** school, f*** softball, f*** cheer, f*** everything", read the message, which was sent to roughly 250 friends, including cheerleading friends at the school. "L.'s [Brandi Levy's] interest in free expression in this case", Supreme Court Justice Stephen Breyer wrote in the ruling. The Supreme Court upheld a lower court ruling, which also found that the school, Mahoney Area High School, violated Brandi Levy's First Amendment rights. That protection must include the protection of unpopular ideas, for popular ideas have less need for protection. Justice Clarence Thomas dissented.

Maggie Hroncich is an intern at The Federalist and a student at Hillsdale College.

The school district and those who sided with it said that schools should be able to punish off-campus speech like Levy's as part of their efforts to regulate cyber-bullying.

President Proud of Working-Class Roots Has Tea With Queen
They saw a Guard of Honour, which Biden inspected, before the Queen led them through the Sovereign's Entrance and served them tea. The Bidens travelled to the Berkshire royal residence on Marine One after attending the G7 summit in Cornwall .

Witold "Vic" Walczak, the legal director of the Pennsylvania ACLU, previously told Insider that school districts effectively had the power to punish the nation's 50 million public-school students for any speech they deemed controversial, even if the students expressed the views off school grounds and outside of school hours.

Levy sued the school district, winning a sweeping victory from a divided three-judge panel of the 3rd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, in Philadelphia.

Levy is now 18 and a freshman at Bloomsburg University. Ambro agreed with the other two judges who decided Levy's case that the suspension was unwarranted, but only because what she did was not disruptive either to the cheerleading team or school. "But sometimes it is necessary to protect the superfluous in order to preserve the necessary", he wrote, using Levy's initials because that was how she was identified in the original lawsuit.

Days before the case was heard in the Supreme Court Tinker and Levy sat down with the ACLU and discussed free speech for students in America.

Related News:



Most liked

Barnaby Joyce Reclaims Nationals Party After Leadership Spill
The spill was moved by Senator Matt Canavan and was wrapped up by 11.30am. "I have always been upfront about my view. WA Nationals leader Mia Davies, who has been a vocal critic of Mr Joyce, on Monday also said she was disappointed.

More than 1 million NM residents have completed COVID-19 shots
The Fraser Health Authority hosted a 32-hour "vax-a-thon" over the weekend, where thousands of people received vaccinations. Across the province, anyone who has not yet registered to be immunized is encouraged by health officials to do so now.

Border measures start easing in July for fully vaccinated Canadians
Starting Monday, any foreign national who holds a valid Confirmation of Permanent Residence (COPR) may also travel to Canada. Travel restrictions for foreign nationals, including USA citizens, remain in place until at least July 21.

Joe Biden's Dog Champ, "Cherished Companion" For 13 Years, Dies
Major returned to the White House in April after being sent to an off-site training so he could adjust to life in the White House. Champ, who was purchased from a Pennsylvania breeder, has been with the Bidens since 2008.

Ontarians cancelling AstraZeneca doses after new guidance
Instead of the 300 million doses Europe sought by the end of September, the court ordered AstraZeneca to ship 80.2 million doses. The donation won't cost Canada anything, and will be on top of the 44 million doses Canada has purchased directly from Moderna.

Close Khamenei loyalist set to win Iran vote
The next Iranian president, who can serve a maximum of two four-year terms, also could be a contender to replace Khamenei, 82. The economy nosedived and spiralling prices fuelled repeated bouts of social unrest which were put down by security forces.

US Catholic bishops approve steps toward possible rebuke of Biden
He warned that the initiative would weaken the bishops' ability to speak on issues such as poverty, racism and the environment. That would leave decisions about Communion for specific churchgoers up to individual bishops and archbishops.

Covid-19: NI records 178 new cases and no further deaths
According to the latest data, it has spread to 356 confirmed cases, with more than 300 in the Calgary health zone. Last Friday, 8,125 new infections were reported, along with 17 deaths.

Edwin Poots stands down as DUP Leader following internal revolt
Party sources told the BBC that the meeting was "robust", and said it had become clear that Mr Poots knew he had to resign. Foster resigned on Monday following her ousting as leader of the Democratic Unionist Party (DUP).

Hong Kong Police Arrest Newspaper Officials Under National Security Law
He said 18 million Hong Kong dollars ($2.32 million) of assets of three Next Digital subsidiaries had been frozen by authorities. Officers said the investigation centred on articles featuring calls for foreign sanctions on Hong Kong and Beijing officials.

China launches first crew to Tiangong space station
The rocket dropped its boosters about two minutes into the flight followed by the cowling surrounding Shenzhou-12. Three Chinese astronauts have docked at China's space station core module, named Tianhe, for the first time.

BC health officials announce 113 new COVID-19 cases, four new deaths
Health officials note that Wednesday's case counts are "provisional" and may be adjusted once they're verified. None of the victims lived in the island region, where 41 people have died since the pandemic began.

Westminster MPs back extension of England's Covid-19 restrictions until 19 July
Moreover, the scientific analysis now in Public Health England journal found no deaths among the vaccinated who were studied. The findings also concluded that the Delta variant affected the younger more affluent group.

Victoria records two new local COVID-19 cases
The complex has been locked down for 14 days after a total of six residents, including an infant, became infected with COVID-19. Dozens of new public exposures sites were published overnight, including several stalls at the popular South Melbourne Market .

IDF prepares for fresh Gaza conflict amid tensions over Jerusalem flag march
The coalition was sworn in on Sunday and includes parties from across the political spectrum, including a small Arab party. Hamas issued a statement calling on Palestinians to show "valiant resistance" to the march.