What Online Retailers Say About the Supreme Court's Tax Ruling

Enlarge this image

States may force online retailers to collect potentially billions of dollars in sales taxes, the U.S. Supreme Court said in a major ruling on Thursday that undercut an advantage many e-commerce companies have enjoyed over brick-and-mortar rivals. Now, under this new decision, even if a company doesn't have a store, warehouse, or office in a state, its internet sales to that state's residents can be taxed. The case is South Dakota v. Wayfair. The decision reverses a 1992 Supreme Court ruling in Quill vs.

The ruling is sure to elate the state's small retailers. But as the e-commerce platform has evolved, more of the larger online retailers have begun paying sales taxes - about 90 percent of the revenue owed.

Amazon isn't the only Seattle company indirectly impacted by the Supreme Court decision. It treats economically identical actors differently for arbitrary reasons.

The matter reached the Supreme Court after South Dakota in 2016 passed a law requiring out-of-state sellers to collect and remit sales taxes, provided the total sales exceeded $100,000 or at least 200 transactions.

The court decision could also be important in Florida because of the state's heavy reliance on sales-tax revenue.

As he noted, the online retail industry has thrived up until now based on the existing rules regarding sales taxes. "It is essential to public confidence in the tax system that the Court avoid creating inequitable exceptions".

As part of the decision, Justice Anthony Kennedy, who wrote for the majority, pointed out how much the landscape has chanced since 1992. Justices Breyer, Sotomayor, and Kagan signed on to Chief Justice Roberts' dissent.

Bloomberg reported that the stocks of Amazon, Wayfair, Etsy, and eBay all fell following the ruling. For decades, these sales tax laws were only applicable on purchases that were made from retailers who had a physical presence within that state.

Sessions says comparing separated children's quarters to Nazi Germany is an "exaggeration"
US Attorney General Jeff Sessions makes a statement regarding national security in NY , U.S., November 2, 2017. Only about 20% of those seeking asylum actually merit it, she said.

President Donald Trump has also criticized Amazon, whose founder Jeff Bezos also owns the Washington Post, saying that it does not collect any sales tax.

Some members of Congress objected to the decision.

Rep. Annie Kuster, D-N.H., said "this misguided ruling will subject them (small businesses) to thousands of taxing jurisdictions and burdensome red tape across the country". That drop eliminated all the gains Overstock enjoyed after it started accepting Bitcoins a few weeks ago which the e-tailer claimed increased sales by over 10%. "Today's landmark decision is a win for South Dakota and for Main Street businesses across America that will now have a level playing field and tax fairness", Jackley said.

The 5-4 opinion, "threw out a precedent that had blocked online sales taxes", Axios explained.

It is not clear how long it might take for online sales taxes to apply universally, or whether new state legislation would be required to implement it in Maryland or Virginia.

In addition, smaller online firms will now be at a disadvantage, not only with local brick-and-mortar businesses that only have to comply with one state's sales-tax laws, but against online giants that can easily absorb the extra compliance costs.

The law went into effect on January 1, said Anna Gill, a spokeswoman for the state Department of Revenue.

Related News:



Most liked

WHO classifies 'gaming disorder' as mental health condition
WHO has been studying the issue and now has formally classified " gaming disorder " as a mental health condition. Continuation or escalation of gaming despite the occurrence of negative consequences .

Bucks' Sterling Brown sues Milwaukee over stun-gun arrest
I'm convinced the only way to get this building's attention and the citizens' attention is to file a federal civil rights suit". Milwaukee Police Department releases body camera video from the arrest of Bucks rookie Sterling Brown .

Paul McCartney sings the Beatles' hits in Carpool Karaoke
They then leave the vehicle to visit the barber's shop mentioned in the song - leaving the owner in sheer disbelief. Setting up hidden cameras around the bar, Corden gave the regular pub-goers a surprise they'd never forget.

Wyden: Verizon to stop selling customers' location
Wireless carriers have been selling that data for years, but it looks like USA operators are now changing their practices a bit. Those types of services can include routing calls to the right facility, fraud prevention and vehicle tracking.

Live streaming, time, teams and where to watch on TV in India
Brazil have won nine of their 10 previous internationals against Costa Rica , losing only in a friendly in March 1960. FIFA World Cup 2018 Live Score, Brazil vs Costa Rica Live Streaming: Neymar will start for Brazil .

South Korea says U.S. drills suspended to aid talks with North
South Korea and Russian Federation have a healthy trade relationship, but geographically speaking, North Korea is in the middle. Ahead of the Singapore meeting, North Korea announced the suspension of its intercontinental ballistic missile (ICBM) testing.

Oil rises ahead of OPEC meeting while trade disputes loom over markets
Saudi Arabia urges OPEC to help consumers by boosting oil supply as opposition from arch-rival Iran shows signs of wavering. Brent crude, the global oil benchmark, was down 1.6% on the day, at $73.54 a barrel, on London's Intercontinental Exchange.

Twitter Temporarily Bans White House Advisor Stephen Miller Phone Sharers
Twitter locked numerous accounts that posted the number, as well as some that retweeted or shared the original Splinter article . Twitter users in turn shared the Splinter information, resulting in Miller's phone blowing up with negative calls and texts.

Melania Trump's Zara jacket shocked many - but statement clothing is in vogue
Then, when people criticize her fashion choices, the first lady is able to respond through a spokesperson by slamming the media. Technically, she's right that there was no hidden message - it was painted, unmistakably, on the jacket's exterior.

World's Oldest Sumatran Orangutan Dies Aged 62
Puan was euthanised on Monday after suffering age-related complications that the zoo said were affecting her quality of life. Puan's 54 descendants have spread across the globe, inhabiting zoos in Europe, the United States, Australia and Singapore.

Kim Jong-un says Beijing and Pyongyang ‘like family’
Bush and who is now senior vice president at the Center for Strategic and International Studies, a Washington think tank. In 2003, during his first stint as premier, he introduced the controversial "July 1 Economic Measures".

Ronaldo becomes Europe's top scorer with strike against MoroccoNaija247news
Despite their valiant display, Morocco will rue the unforgivable defending that made all their subsequent good work irrelevant. Portugal talisman Cristiano Ronaldo is on course to surpass the legendary Ferenc Puskas on the list of most worldwide goals.

Nabil Fekir could still join Liverpool
It appears this frustrating transfer saga for Liverpool supporters still has a few more turns left. Liverpool's bid to sign Nabil Fekir from Lyon is not over, according to the player's agent.

WHO classifies video game addiction a mental health disorder
Addictively playing video game Fortnite could indicate something more worrisome, according to the World Health Organization . According to the newly updated classification, there are three major signs to diagnose gaming disorder in a person.

Instagram’s vertical answer to YouTube — Here’s IGTV
At launch, IGTV videos can be up to 10 minutes long, while select creators will be allowed to make videos up to 60 minutes long. Instagram , which Facebook bought in 2012 for $1 billion, has grown by adding features like messaging and short videos.